Recent AWS Customer Success Stories & Videos

More AWS Customer Success Stories...

« Amazon S3 Price Reduction | Main | Pulse – Using Big Data Analytics to Drive Rich User Features »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c534853ef0167622d6640970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Be Careful When Comparing AWS Costs...:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Philip Arnason

Thanks for responding to the Gigaom article, I was hoping to see an official AWS response. One will never get a truly fair apples to apples comparison at a high level because every project is different. Moving existing services to IAAS/PAAS comes with its' own rearchitecting application costs.

Despite the challenges, I am very bullish on IAAS. I feel like this sector is in the same position VMware was in 2003: Lots of FUD yet corporations slowly but surely "dipping their feet in the pool", unable to ignore the vast amount of potential.

Philip Arnason

Manoel

nice explanation about GIGAOM comparison costs post. regards.

Jeff Schneider

Hey Jeff,
One more item you might include in your cost analysis is monitoring. The AWS CloudWatch Basic Monitoring package is provided free of charge. This isn't the case with many hosting solutions.
Jeff

John Swords

Hey Jeff, thanks for the quick work on this. Was curious about their methodology.

CombinaMaster

I agree...I commented earlier on gigaom website. This is not apple to apple comparison. Amazon AWS solution is defiantly more advantageous to the smaller operation vs. the large scale one.

Pritesh

Agreed on this. Couple of month ago we have moved from Self hosted to AWS with 3 year reserved instance and client really happy in terms of saving cost.

Interested read below entries.
Price comparison between on demand, one year reserved instance and three year v instance.
http://www.cfminds.com/post.cfm/saving-with-ec2-reserved-instance-aws

Case study of implementation:
http://www.cfminds.com/post.cfm/case-study-hauntworld-com-aws-implementation

Dave Dopson

You guys are being too generous. That article wasn't just "apples to oranges", it was totally disingenuous. They focused entirely on "bandwidth" and totally ignored all the major issues associated with rolling your own self-hosting ("well just assume labor is the same").

They had a medium scale deployment that was 60k to setup in a colo vs 70k of AWS fees. Even if they hadn't done the math wrong and it actually was 70k on AWS .... really? You are going to own and operate 150 servers for a year for only 10k ??? You are going handle financing the upfront costs? And deal with predicting capacity, because you know exactly how much hardware you will need months in advance and your needs never change? And deal with RMA of dead hardware? And figure out how to image all the physical boxes. And find a second colo site for availability. Really? You want to deal with all that crap and take a much larger capital risk just to save a measly $10k???

At the scale of a Google or Zynga, you can amortize the costs of figuring this stuff out. Anyone who doesn't have special hardware needs and wants to run their own 150 server deployment is bordering on insane.

Iamgavitron

another point to mention, is that in an AWS solution, you would offload your static resources (images, flash, etc) to a CDN (like cloudfront,) giving you a further reduction in costs, as the gigaom comparison assumes that you would be transiting all web traffic via your ELB.

Also, I think to disregard labour is disingenuous; By properly automating server builds against the AWS apis, we spin new machines automatically in seconds, whereas to do the same in a self-hosted environment I have to create (and service) a VM infrastructure with UEC or VSphere - not a small or cheap undertaking, especially at multi-region scale.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Featured Events

The AWS Report


Brought to You By

Jeff Barr (@jeffbarr):



Jinesh Varia (@jinman):


Email Subscription

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

April 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30